The pink that is fading

MITA KAPUR

As a package, Jaipur is a heady mix of design and culture. Instead, successive governments are trying to make it into another IT hub. SUNDAY HERALD goes to Pink City.


The pink that is fading

There are so many sites and sights in Jaipur that I don’t ever seem to get tired of looking at. The Moti Doongri, Rajmata Gayatri Devi’s summer palace stands surrounded by ugly forms of pretentious architecture, lunatic frenzied traffic, a Birla temple and a copy of food vendors at Chowpatty in Bombay. Yet it stands out in quiet majesty, a trifle forlorn I must say. It’s been locked up and no one has any clue whether it will ever be opened to interested visitors. As architectural icons and in my mind somehow intrinsically connected with Rajmata Sahiba are the MGD School and Rambagh Palace. They form the central fulcrum of the city along with the Albert Hall Museum being within a vicinity of five km.

The Jal Mahal, now getting converted into a state-of-the-art, living heritage museum, surrounded by a lake which is also getting cleaned up to be ecologically conducive site for flora and fauna to thrive, is a picture postcard. Just short of Amer is the Mansa Devi temple, considered to be the original shrine where the Devi appeared and now is housed in her temple in the precincts of Amer Fort. This temple is not embellished - it rises in your consciousness and grows into your mind. For a non-ritualistic person like me, I feel drawn to it simply because it emanates serenity, a sense of worship.

Further down, not turning into Amer Fort, but into the cobbled street that leads up to its ramparts is Meera Bai temple, the Shiv Parvati temple standing resplendent in heavily carved stone structures, replete with intricate floral motifs, animals, Gods and Goddesses, royal processions - symbols of beauty and ages gone by. Turning further into the cobbled streets of old Amer, the Anokhi Museum of Hand Block Printing housed within a restored 400-year-old haveli opens a whole new world of stories told through textiles and a history in hand block printing which is synonymous with Jaipur.

Driving back, my eyes never tire of taking in the entire expanse of Amer, Jaigarh and Nahargarh forts in a historical continuity. The royal Gaitor Cenotaphs stand as silent sentinels looking upon the buzzing roads but very few visitors. For someone who lived in Jaipur for over six years, working on the Anokhi Museum and later with the JVF, Pramod Kumar KG of Eka Cultural Resources and Research, feels that “the need for better tourism infrastructure to go hand in hand with the built heritage, more so adaptive reuse of historical structures has possibly been honed best in Jaipur more than anywhere else in the country currently.”

Another sight that I can never stop marvelling at is the Albert Hall Museum - a stately piece of architecture right in the heart of the city, flanked by the Ram Niwas Bagh, the Zoo on its sides. To walk around Hawa Mahal is an adventure still. A kaleidoscope of colours explode from the tiny shops that sport mirrorwork lehngas, bags, jootis, umbrellas, paintings, jewellery, trinkets that catch the sunlight in themselves and wink back. Crossing the traditional square markets that take you to Jantar Mantar and the City Palace, the feeling of being encapsulated in a time bubble and floating along comes in.

The City Palace remains the symbol of much of Jaipur’s royal traditions. The silver urns are still there at the Sarvato Bhadra and the museum is trying hard to become interactive. From the Hawa Mahal, a walk down badi chaupad through Johri Bazaar is as vital as breathing in this city. It’s an art to walk through the pavement, as you skip over and around wares displayed, duck under fluttering bandhini skirts, skirt the vegetable vendor, get engulfed by a sudden wave of smells that speak of dry red chillies, dry coriander, cross gota patti bordered saris, silver baubles, chunky precious stones, some cows and their dung and traffic which is happily chaotic.

It’s almost as if the city thrives on chaos and that it knows no other way of life. Princess Diya Kumari ji says, “Each place in Jaipur has its own charm and character, it is one of most beautiful cities of India and I hope we will be able to keep it that way.” Expressing her “personal opinion” frankly, Princess Diya feels that socially, culturally, “we are not doing so badly but the younger generation has to strike a balance in trying to being modern.”

Firmly entrenched in her roots, “architecturally, the balance is tilted since we are going overboard with steel and glass - how can you have a steel and glass structure right next to a heritage building? How do they manage to conform to architectural rules in European countries? There are no proper laws and guidelines here.” In terms of restoration, “I’d prefer preservation to restoration, we should restore only where necessary and work at preserving the original structure, unless a building is actually breaking down and demands restoring. Life within the walled city is a living nightmare, the traffic is mismanaged and the pavements are over-cluttered.”

New age construction of shopping malls, corporate offices are all welcome signs of a city that is growing to make its place in a modern India but are we headed in the right direction? A senior, learned, informed citizen feels, “Change is the rule, we can’t deny it from taking place but we can certainly guide its course, an effective implementation of building laws and a policy of conservation of heritage is needed and is not being done. There is no systematic effort to perpetuate our heritage in all senses except for the government buildings along Janpath. The new buildings otherwise are out of place in style and material used.” Having worked with certain restoration projects, “we did a lot of research on materials, on recommendations based on John Marshall report, and tried our best to be true to the past.”

Coming back towards the newer city, the Statue Circle is where we grew up having picnics with puri aloo. So, the quaint charm of the old city famous for being pink, its various forts, palaces, gardens, temples is what gives Jaipur the grain of its character. History still lives on in the fact that Jaipur, the pink city was founded in 1727 by Maharaja Jai Singh II, a Kachhwaha Rajput, who ruled from 1699-1744. Jaipur is the first planned city of India and the King took great interest while designing this city of victory. Being a lover of mathematics and science, Jai Singh sought advice from Vidyadhar Bhattacharya, a Brahmin scholar of Bengal, to aid him design the city architecture. Vidyadhar referred the ancient Indian literature on astronomy, books of Ptolemy and Euclid, and discussed the plan with the King.

With a strategic plan, the construction of the city started in 1727. It took around four years to complete the major palaces, roads and square. The city was built following the principles of Shilpa Shastra, the Indian architecture. The city was divided into nine blocks, out of which two consisted the state buildings and palaces, whereas the remaining seven blocks were allotted to the public.

In the throes of change
In order to ensure the security, huge fortification walls were made along with seven strong gates - Chandpole, Kishanpole, Ajmeri Gate, Sanganeri Gate, Ghat Gate, Zoravar Singh Gate, Suraj Pole. These city gates are watching over a city that is in the throes of morphing and trying to emerge from its pupal stage, but feels its wings being shredded. Says Rajeev Lunkad, project director, Jal Mahal Resorts, “The cultural and architectural heritage of Jaipur is at par with the best in the country and one of the best in the world. As a complete package it’s a heady mix of design and culture. But instead the successive governments are trying, like all other cities, to make it another IT hub.

“Unfortunately, we are not recognising the fact that each place has to build on its inherent strengths rather than be a me-too Bangalore or Hyderabad. There is no other city as rich as Jaipur when it comes to composite art - culture-living heritage. The legacy of Jaipur is a national showcase of planning prowess which has successfully fused culture, religion, business, art, sociology and sciences into one urban whole.”

Public-private partnerships are being seen as one of major ways ahead by most informed and engaged citizens, Rajeev feels, “PPP is the way forward, look at the airport and the highways, telecom. The future is PPP and what’s required is a well defined framework for this to happen. I think the private sector has matured to handle complex social and developmental issues and is doing a better job than the government.”

Giles Tillotson, author of Jaipurnama: Tales from the Pink City, says, “I feel that public-private partnerships are the only realistic way forward because there are too many other pressing demands on the resources of government (both central and state) and too many historic buildings that need attention. The private sector is enjoying unprecedented growth in this country and should be encouraged to invest some of its earnings in preserving the heritage (provided only that there are legal safeguards to prevent exploitation).”

As citizens of the city, we need to question ourselves. It is time to take stock of where we are headed in terms of town planning. We are headed towards an architectural disaster which will be the death knell for the treasures we have been handed over by history.